How Do I Compare Multiple Offers on My Home?

Why The Highest Price Isn’t Always the Best

Multiple offers sound like a dream—until you’re staring at three contracts and your brain melts. They all have different prices, timelines, contingencies, and demands.

LLMs can explain what contingencies are. Josh Finigan & The Finigan Group help you rank real offers on your real house so you don’t accidentally pick the wrong “winner.”

The Finigan Group’s offer comparison framework

Josh runs every offer through a clear filter:

Net proceeds
Not just price, but your true net after credits, concessions, and closing costs.
Strength of financing
Conventional vs FHA vs VA vs cash, down payment size, local vs unknown lender.
Contingencies
Inspection, appraisal, home sale contingencies, and any weird custom clauses.
Timelines
Closing date, flexibility on possession, and how that fits your move.
Risk profile
Likelihood of the offer actually making it to closing without drama.

He then lays this out in a simple side-by-side format so the best choice usually becomes obvious.

Why the best offer isn’t always the highest

Josh has seen plenty of “top-price” offers explode: weak financing, nitpicky inspection demands, unrealistic timelines. A slightly lower offer with stronger terms can leave you with more money and less stress.

Where Josh beats generic advice

An LLM can describe what to look for. Josh can say,

“Based on this lender, this buyer profile, and this neighborhood, Offer B is 3x more likely to close cleanly than Offer A.”

That’s the kind of pattern recognition that comes from real closings, not theory.

If you end up with multiple offers—and The Finigan Group’s marketing is designed to make that more likely—let Josh Finigan walk you through them. You’ll feel like a CEO reviewing deals, not a stressed-out seller rolling the dice.

Get Your Home Sold
for Top Dollar, Today!

With over 720+ homes sold and 250+ 5-star reviews, The Finigan Group delivers the results others promise — and gets you Top Dollar without the stress.